WA Church speaks out: we will not facilitate euthanasia

As euthanasia becomes legal in WA from 1 July, that state's Catholic healthcare agencies and institutions will not allow or encourage the practice in any circumstances

Reading Time: 6 minutes
Form 1 July euthanasia is legal in Western Australia. But the state’s Catholic healthcare system and associated agencies will not comply with the practice in any way. Photo” Freepik.com

The Catholic Church in Western Australia has this week entered a new world order with the enacting of the state’s 2019 Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill.

The legislation, passed by the McGowan government on 10 December 2019, allows Western Australians who are terminally ill to legally end their lives at a time of their choosing.

This means that the legislation will apply to the WA Catholic heath care acute, aged and disability sectors, including St John of God Hospitals, MercyCare, Mercy Health, Catholic Homes, Southern Cross Care, Nazareth Care, Little Sisters of the Poor and Mount La Verna aged care facilities, in addition to Identitywa as a disability care service, and the University of Notre Dame Australia as a medical teaching facility.

NSW push also expected

The enactment of WA’s legislation comes as NSW Independent MP Alex Greenwich is expected to officially launch his draft bill this month to enable voluntary assisted dying and euthanasia in this state. Mr Greenwich has indicated his bill would be largely based on the Western Australian model.

In WA, those who make the decision to end their life must be diagnosed with what is classified as a terminal 1 illness or medical condition that will, on the balance of probabilities, cause death within six months, or within 12 months for some conditions. They must have decision-making capacity in relation to voluntary assisted dying.

During the process the individual must make three separate requests for voluntary assisted dying: a first request, a written declaration and a final request. The written declaration must be witnessed by two people who meet specific requirements.

Archbishop Timothy Costelloe SDB of Perth has issued a pastoral letter declaring no Catholic institution will provide or facilitate euthanasia or assisted suicide. Photo: Archdiocese of Perth

Archbishop issues pastoral

In light of the legislation that was enacted on 1 July, Perth Archbishop Timothy Costelloe SDB last week delivered a Pastoral Letter, which highlighted that every human life, from its earliest beginnings at conception to its final moments leading to death, is precious and sacrosanct.

“No-one has the right to ‘step in’ and bring to an end a life that has begun under God’s providence and will come to its end under God’s providence,” Archbishop Costelloe said in the letter.

“We also believe, precisely because life is precious and sacred, that it is to be respected at every moment: when the child is still in its mother’s womb, when it grows to be an infant, then a young child, then an adolescent and an adult.

We will not provide assisted suicide

“We believe that whether a person is sick or well, weak or strong, poor or wealthy, in agreement with us or in opposition to us, educated or illiterate, generous or selfish, faithful or faithless, living or dying, that person is to be treated with dignity and respect: everything that can be done to give meaning and hope to every person must be done,” Archbishop Costelloe wrote.

In an exclusive interview, the Archdiocese of Perth’s LJ Goody Bioethics Director, Dr Joe Parkinson explained how the legislation will be operationalised within the WA Catholic health care sector acute care, aged care and disability care organisations.

“Our services have agreed that we will not provide or facilitate VAD,” Dr Parkinson explained.

Catholic agencies to develop protocols

The acute care, aged care, disability care and community services elements of the WA Catholic health care sector represent some 2000 private and public hospital beds and more than 6000 residential and home care packages across Western Australia.

“The WA Catholic health, disability and aged care sector work to provide the best care possible for our patients, residents and clients, and for our staff who will have to adjust to the advent of Voluntary Assisted Dying,” Dr Parkinson explained.

Dr Parkinson continued by highlighting that each Catholic health, disability and aged care service provider has agreed on basic principles that preserve the long-standing Catholic commitment to excellent end-of-life care, and each service will develop its own protocols for operationalising those principles.

From 1 July, Voluntary Assisted Dying is legal throughout the state of Western Australia. Photo: Rawpixel

No involvement in any steps

“To begin with, we recognise that wherever we deliver aged care or disability care services, it will usually be in the client or resident’s own home setting and they have a right (under Federal legislation) to make any other care arrangements they like.

“So, we cannot impede their right to seek Voluntary Assisted Dying (VAD) privately, and we will comply with the VAD Act in providing statutory information about VAD.

“However, we will not authorise any of our caregivers to be involved in any of the steps required for the client to access VAD, including facilitating assessments for eligibility and helping them to obtain and use the VAD substances.

Staff will be trained

Dr Parkinson continued by explaining that the Catholic sector wants residents and clients to talk to them freely about any care concerns they may have, including seeking information about VAD or their wish to access VAD.

“We are training staff to be available for these conversations, so that we can identify and deliver the kind of care the resident or client actually needs at the time,” Dr Parkinson explained.

“If a resident or client wishes to consult a VAD Navigator they will be able to do so privately, even on our premises, but our staff will not be authorised to assist, other than to put the resident or client in touch with the Navigator Service for the purposes of obtaining information.

No assistance

If a resident or client wishes to consult an external doctor for the purposes of VAD eligibility assessment and associated processes, they will be free to do so. However, Catholic sector staff will not assist in any way.

It is also against the law for health care workers to raise the issue of voluntary assisted dying with a resident or client.

“If a resident or client wishes to make private arrangements to receive and use VAD substances they will not be impeded, but again our staff will not be authorised to assist in any way,” Dr Parkinson emphasised.

“And we will need to pay close attention to the safe storage of and access to the substances,” he said.

Staff do not have to talk about voluntary assisted dying with the resident or client if they don’t want to – also known as ‘conscientious objection’.

Dr Parkinson also noted that the Catholic sector does not want to see patients or aged care residents transferred out of their facilities for the purposes of obtaining VAD, “although of course we will not impede any who wish and are assessed as clinically safe to do so … Likewise if a hospital asks to return a resident or client to our care we will accept them, even if they intend to pursue VAD, but our staff will not be authorised to assist with the VAD process itself,” Dr Parkinson said.

Our basic stance is that we would prefer to look after all our patients, residents and clients ourselves, because we believe we are able to provide the best available standard of care in all of its physical, psychological, social, and spiritual dimensions.

“Our basic stance is that we would prefer to look after all our patients, residents and clients ourselves, because we believe we are able to provide the best available standard of care in all of its physical, psychological, social, and spiritual dimensions.

“That includes end-of-life care,” he said. Ending his Pastoral Letter published on 23 June, Archbishop Costelloe highlighted the need to support, through prayer and encouragement, all those who are engaged in the healing and caring ministry of the Church.

“Our Catholic hospitals, our Catholic aged-care facilities, our Catholic nursing homes and our Catholic Social Outreach agencies are already committed to being places of compassion, of healing, and of hope.

“With the legalisation of VAD, the witness of all these wonderful institutions to the Catholic understanding of the dignity and sanctity of every human life will become even more important,” he wrote, adding “It will also become more challenging.”

Jamie O’Brien is Communications Manager of the Archdiocese of Perth and Editor of The Record

Related