Fr Josh Miechels: good ideas and a few howlers in Plenary papers

Reading Time: 4 minutes
Young Catholics gather at the Australian Catholic Youth Festival in 2017. The Plenary has enormous potential for good in the life of the Church, especially for the young and those who are searching. Keeping it on track is vital. Photo: Giovanni Portelli

Good ideas – and a few ‘howlers’ in new Plenary documents

The six discernment papers for the Plenary Council have been published and they provide interesting insights into who we think we are and what we think God is and the Church is.

It is obvious that the papers include input from wildly different theological views. Drawing these together must have involved skillful management and patient guidance. To the Chairs – kudos!

There are good things in the proposals. The attention and space dedicated to the poor and those ‘on the margins’ is one of the more significant examples. The proposal for a marriage catechumenate to address the crisis in marriage is another.

Howlers?

There are also some howlers. The more exciting non-starters include discussion on women priests, the uncaring push for general Third Rite confession (which still requires First Rite anyway), and ‘collaborating’ with priests by removing them – from preaching, weddings, baptisms, funerals, and administering parishes.

What is troubling is that a main response common to all six papers to the problems of the Church’s disassociation from youth, lack of vocations, plummeting Mass numbers and lack of fruitfulness is – what? An ocean of bureaucracy. Committees and councils and consultations for every diocese and every single parish. In short a new permanent political (“laity are elected”) and bureaucratic hierarchy.

Given most people find bureaucracy as attractive as a wizard’s armpit, and that this bureaucratic approach was trialled extensively in the 70s and 80s and with a few exceptions wound up (or died) in the 90s – surely we can finally try something new.

Bureaucracy isn’t the answer

Its good to see public recognition of Vatican II’s universal call to all of us to conversion and mission. But that call is not to a single state of life. On the contrary, Vatican II quite clearly recognises that there are at least three different states of life – lay, consecrated and clerical – with very different roles and responsibilities. Part of the poverty of the bureaucratic option is the intolerance of difference and the scant attention paid to the new communities the Holy Spirit has already raised up – full of examples of how differing states of life can work together in ways that already work.

Catholics need to be familiar with what Vatican II – the landmark event in the life of the modern church – actually said and taught, rather than what they feel it did. Distinguishing between the two things is vital if the Church is to move forward and prosper.

The real game: holiness

One thing is for sure: young people and young families, and most people really, are not going to come back to the Church because they have a seat at a committee meeting, or because the bureaucracy has pushed back the clergy. I mean, if that’s what the Church is – why would you join? As any priest can tell you – people’s profound preoccupations are: How can I cope with suffering? Where is an antidote to atheist pointlessness? Where can I find that joy my soul desires? Who will free me? What is my identity? What is the point of my life? How can I peacefully be by myself? Who will love me in a flawless and unending manner?

How can I cope with suffering? Where is an antidote to atheist pointlessness? It’s these questions and others that all of us – lay, consecrated and clergy – have the task to answer in a life of missionary holiness. PHOTO: Giovanni Portelli

These are the questions all of us – lay, consecrated and clergy – have the task to answer in a life of missionary holiness. People join the Catholic Church because they see saints. It is the cultivation of saints – of a flood of devout families, prayerful missionary young people, joyful consecrated brothers and sisters, holy priests and courageous bishops – not bureaucracy, that will save the Church, and crucially, save the souls of all of those outside of her – who long for what we already have.

Related

No easy answers as Plenary papers released
Plenary 2020: the creeping clericalisation of the laity