• Home
  • News
    • Advertorial
    • Archbishop
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Education
    • National
    • NSW
    • Politics
    • Royal Commission
    • Sports
    • Synod
    • Vatican
    • World
    • Youth
  • Opinion
    • Anna Krohn
    • Archbishop Opinion
    • Fr. John Flader
    • George Weigel
    • Kevin Donnelly
    • Mark Shea
    • Monica Doumit
    • Simcha Fisher
  • Features
    • Health & Wellbeing
    • Quiz
  • Faith
    • Family & Marriage
    • Relationships
    • Religious Life
    • Saints
  • Parenting
  • Multimedia
    • Galleries
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
  • Plenary 2020
  • Subscribe
    • My Account
    • Print Subscription
    • Free Digital Editions
    • Advertise
    • Newsletter Subscription
    • Share Your Story
      • Terms and Conditions for Contributors
    • Circulation
    • Jobs
    • Contact
  •  
Sign in
Welcome!Log into your account
Forgot your password?
Privacy Policy
Password recovery
Recover your password
Search
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Privacy Policy
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
The Catholic Weekly The Catholic Weekly
- Advertisement -
The Catholic Weekly The Catholic Weekly
  • Home
  • News
    • AllAdvertorialArchbishopArts & EntertainmentEducationNationalNSWPoliticsRoyal CommissionSportsSynodVaticanWorldYouth
      News

      Call for prayers after death of Archbishop Philip Wilson

      Syriac Catholic artist Ghusoon Durdur with her painting depicting the invasion of her parish by ISIS in Northern Iraq. Photo: Giovanni Portelli
      News

      Art, talent flourish in adversity

      The average time from design to completion of a model is four to six months. Photo: Giovanni Portelli
      News

      Details are key for sub-deacon

      Education

      Vatican COVID-19 chief to speak at ACU forum

  • Opinion
    • AllAnna KrohnArchbishop OpinionFr. John FladerGeorge WeigelKevin DonnellyMark SheaMonica DoumitSimcha Fisher
      Opinion

      Philippa Martyr: Our giant credibility problem

      Opinion

      Dr Kevin Donnelly: UK consciously drops the unconscious bias

      $2.3 billion over six years, it is reported. Surely that’s worth looking into, Victoria Police? Photo: unsplash.com
      Monica Doumit

      Monica Doumit: Show us the money

      Opinion

      Dr Kevin Donnelly: Techniques to obscure the truth

  • Features
    • AllHealth & WellbeingQuiz
      Health & Wellbeing

      New Greater Sydney rules: masks at Mass and congregations of 100

      Health & Wellbeing

      Vatican issues 20-point call for equitable vaccine access

      Health & Wellbeing

      A vaccine for all: 20 points for a fairer world

      Religious Life

      60 years a Brother with no regrets

  • Faith
    • AllFamily & MarriageRelationshipsReligious LifeSaints
      Relationships

      Young couple find happiness in their return to the faith

      Faith

      Fr Brian Lucas: Women and Service at the Altar

      Archdiocese News

      Padre in Paris: Fr Josh’s Mission trip to France

      Relationships

      Pope announces year-long reflection on family, ‘Amoris Laetitia’

  • Parenting
  • Multimedia
    • Galleries
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
  • Plenary 2020
    • Plenary 2020

      Peter McGregor: Prayerful and Eucharistic Plenary Council Paper

      Archdiocese News

      Plenary ‘map’ is well in hand, says President

      A collection of biblical manuscripts. Photo: CNS photo/courtesy Museum of the Bible
      Plenary 2020

      Peter McGregor: Comments on The Plenary Council Paper

      Opinion

      Precisely which Church? A response to the Plenary Discernment papers

      Opinion

      Fr Josh Miechels: good ideas and a few howlers in Plenary…

  • Subscribe
    • My Account
    • Print Subscription
    • Free Digital Editions
    • Advertise
    • Newsletter Subscription
    • Share Your Story
      • Terms and Conditions for Contributors
    • Circulation
    • Jobs
    • Contact
  •  
Home Opinion What the left can learn from Pope Francis
  • News
  • Opinion

What the left can learn from Pope Francis

By
Adrian Pabst
-
October 19, 2020
Share
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
Linkedin
Email
Print
    Reading Time: 6 minutes
    Pope Francis poses for a selfie with a man after Holy Thursday Mass of the Lord’s Supper at the Center for Asylum Seekers in Castelnuovo di Porto. Photo: CNS/L’Osservatore Romano

    Mindful of our fractured world, the pope calls for a fairer sharing of resources, care for nature, and compassion for migrants. 

    What does the left stand for? Social democrats across the West seem stuck, unable to move beyond the binary option of centrist technocracy or revolutionary populism. Devoid of ideas and energy, the left suffers defeat and division while the right reinvents itself and rules. Missing from progressive politics is a sense of purpose beyond rights and utility – a vision of human flourishing anchored in fraternity and friendship. Such a vision can be found in Pope Francis’s social encyclical “Fratelli Tutti”, published on 4 October.

    The contemporary left lacks a distinctive conception of the good life

    The contemporary left lacks a distinctive conception of the good life. Appeals to left-wing values ring increasingly hollow. Of the three foundational values that have dominated politics since the French Revolution – liberty, equality and fraternity – the left has privileged the first two at the expense of the third. Yet without fraternity, liberty slides into individualistic free choice removed from the relational constraints of family or community. Equality becomes debased to mean either sameness or difference. As a result, the left is caught in an impasse between imposing uniform standards and promoting individualised identities.

    Londoners participate in a protest by the Extinction Rebellion global environmental movement. PHOTO: Takver/Flickr, CC BY-SA 2.0

    Fraternity itself has been redefined. Whereas it used to denote interpersonal relations embedded in decentralised mutual aid organisations, it has come to designate impersonal solidarity provided by the central state via top-down redistribution. In this process, the intermediary institutions of civic society lost much of their agency and were subsumed under the joint power of state and market. The left version of being free and equal abstracts from social roles and relationships.

    “Over time this has led to left-wing support for free-market capitalism, extreme identity politics and an obsession with technology. Far from producing progress, these forces exacerbate divisions that have been decades in the making – rising levels of economic inequality, social fragmentation and family breakdown,” writes Adrian Pabst. Photo: Peter Rosengren

    Over time this has led to left-wing support for free-market capitalism, extreme identity politics and an obsession with technology. Far from producing progress, these forces exacerbate divisions that have been decades in the making – rising levels of economic inequality, social fragmentation and family breakdown. But growing polarisation will not be resolved by doubling down on technocratic or populist politics. Instead, the left abandons its traditional supporters and keeps losing elections, as happened to Labour under Corbyn in 2019.

    [see also: Rabbi Jonathan Sacks’s Diary: Rediscovering the common good, Passover in isolation, and lessons from a gulag survivor]

    To recover a moral compass, the left should heed Francis’s call for “a new vision of fraternity and social friendship”. Fraternity is a universal disposition, the idea that we ought to love every human being because we all have dignity. Friendship is a particular moral sentiment, the affection we have for those we encounter. Fraternal love enables friendship as the strangers in our midst become our neighbours. In the Pope’s own words, “every brother or sister in need, when abandoned or ignored by the society in which I live, becomes an existential foreigner, even though born in the same country”. Social friendship, he writes, creates a “true universal openness”, as opposed to “the false universalism of those who constantly travel abroad because they cannot tolerate or love their own people”. But it is not only liberal globalism the pontiff takes aim at. He rejects populist nationalism and its demagogic exploitation of fear in order to attain power. The constructive alternative Francis seeks to chart balances “love of one’s native land and a sound sense of belonging to our larger human family”.

    Pope Francis is determined to take the oxygen out of the “culture wars”

    The pope’s intervention is vital for the left as it tries to regain popular trust. Mindful of our fractured world, he calls for a more just sharing of the world’s resources, care for our common home of nature – the subject of his previous encyclical – and compassion for migrants. Linking greater economic justice and ecological balance to social fairness will help the left to renew its ethical traditions anchored in the common good, beyond utilitarian or rights-based models. The left will also appreciate his unequivocal condemnation of Christians who are apologists of xenophobia, racism and ethnocentric atavism.

    The left will also appreciate his unequivocal condemnation of Christians who are apologists of xenophobia, racism and ethnocentric atavism. Many Christians in reaction to the left have tended towards ring wing populism which also go against Christian social ethics. Pope Francis condemns such behaviour. Pictured here are neonazis at the infamous Unite the Right Rally in Charlottesville which resulted in the death of counter-protestor Heather Heyer by right wing extremists PHOTO: Wikimedia Commons CC BY 2.0 Evan Nesterak

    At the same time, Pope Francis is determined to take the oxygen out of the “culture wars” that are ripping Western societies apart. Against left-wing protesters who tear down statutes and dismiss whole cultures as reactionary, he reminds people to know their history, learn from the experiences of their elders and be open to the inheritance from past generations. “People who abandon their tradition,” the pope writes, “and allow others to rob their very soul, end up losing… their moral consistency and, in the end, their intellectual, economic and political independence.” It is a powerful rebuttal to the advocates of “cancel culture” and the closing of the progressive mind.

    [see also: Covid and confronting our own mortality]

    Key to the practice of fraternity is a balance of rights with obligations. Selfishness enslaves us to our own fabricated desires, whereas caring for ourselves and for others makes us free. True equality involves a hierarchy in which the young have a duty to look after the elderly, just as the elderly are obligated to impart wisdom which the young cannot achieve on their own. The left forgets that the family remains the fundamental social institution that educates us into the social virtues of sacrifice and service on which citizenship and democracy depend. Social virtues rest on lived fraternity – relationships of “give-and-receive” that give our daily lives meaning.

    The left needs to recover ethical traditions to be a force for good

    The left can learn from Catholic social teaching a politics of the common good, motivated by fraternal love, that rebuilds broken societies. Such a politics starts with the things that matter most to people – their families and friends, the places where they live and work, the relationships of support and community that sustain them, and the institutions that provide security. Love, home, work and hope are the building blocks for the good life that fuses our individual fulfilment with the mutual flourishing of others.

    A nun leads prayer for displaced Iraqi Christians who fled Islamic State militants in Mosul at a school acting as a refugee camp in Irbil, Iraq, in 2014. At the time, Irbil hosted more than 100,000 displaced Christians and other minorities. In the years to come, that number soared. Source: Ahmed Jadallah, Reuters

    Fraternity is at the heart of the social fabric binding together communities and countries. The left needs to recover ethical traditions to be a force for good – gaining and retaining power to offer people a more dignified life. – newstatesman.com

    Read Fratelli Tutti here

    Adrian Pabst is head of the School of Politics and International Relations at the University of Kent and a New Statesman contributing writer. He is the author of Liberal World Order and Its Critics (Routledge). Follow him on Twitter: @AdrianPabst1​.

    Related Stories:

    • Fratelli Tutti outlines vision for a better world
    • New course on Church’s social teaching
    • Like a century ago, a papal encyclical tries to shed light on a dark time
    • TAGS
    • Catholic Social Teaching
    • culture wars
    • Fratelli Tutti
    • Identity Politics
    • Left Wing Politics
    • Pope Francis
    Share
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Pinterest
    Linkedin
    Email
    Print
      Previous articleQ&A with Fr John Flader: The campaign for death
      Next articleGeorge Weigel: Papal states had to go
      Avatar
      Adrian Pabst
      Adrian Pabst is head of the School of Politics and International Relations at the University of Kent and a New Statesman contributing writer. He is the author of Liberal World Order and Its Critics (Routledge). Follow him on Twitter: @AdrianPabst1.

      RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

      News

      Call for prayers after death of Archbishop Philip Wilson

      Opinion

      Philippa Martyr: Our giant credibility problem

      Syriac Catholic artist Ghusoon Durdur with her painting depicting the invasion of her parish by ISIS in Northern Iraq. Photo: Giovanni Portelli
      News

      Art, talent flourish in adversity

      Cart

      - Advertisement -

      FEATURES

      Health & Wellbeing

      New Greater Sydney rules: masks at Mass and congregations of 100

      Peter Rosengren - January 2, 2021
      Premier Berejiklian defended her decision on the go-ahead for the New Year's Test as necessary to preserve jobs and keep public morale high

      Vatican issues 20-point call for equitable vaccine access

      December 31, 2020

      A vaccine for all: 20 points for a fairer world

      December 31, 2020

      60 years a Brother with no regrets

      December 28, 2020

      MOST POPULAR

      Call for prayers after death of Archbishop Philip Wilson

      January 18, 2021

      Philippa Martyr: Our giant credibility problem

      January 17, 2021
      Syriac Catholic artist Ghusoon Durdur with her painting depicting the invasion of her parish by ISIS in Northern Iraq. Photo: Giovanni Portelli

      Art, talent flourish in adversity

      January 17, 2021
      - Advertisement -

      Recent Posts

      Call for prayers after death of Archbishop Philip Wilson

      January 18, 2021

      Philippa Martyr: Our giant credibility problem

      January 17, 2021
      Syriac Catholic artist Ghusoon Durdur with her painting depicting the invasion of her parish by ISIS in Northern Iraq. Photo: Giovanni Portelli

      Art, talent flourish in adversity

      January 17, 2021

      Archdiocesan News

      Bishop Terry Brady preaches at the 100th anniversary Mass at St Brigid’s in Coogee. Photo: Giovanni Portelli

      Faithful mark Eileen’s centenary

      January 14, 2021

      Padre in Paris: Fr Josh’s Mission trip to France

      January 11, 2021

      Simcha Fisher: The fairy tale of America

      January 8, 2021

      Latest Opinion

      Philippa Martyr: Our giant credibility problem

      January 17, 2021

      Dr Kevin Donnelly: UK consciously drops the unconscious bias

      January 16, 2021
      $2.3 billion over six years, it is reported. Surely that’s worth looking into, Victoria Police? Photo: unsplash.com

      Monica Doumit: Show us the money

      January 15, 2021
      The Catholic Weekly
      ABOUT US
      The Catholic Weekly is proudly Catholic, proudly counter-cultural, proudly in favour of life. We strive to share our vision of the Church, the Lord and the life-changing possibilities of the Christian path with our readers, providing a degree of Catholic News clarity for complex times.
      Contact us: [email protected]
      FOLLOW US
      • Share Your Story
      • Privacy Policy
      • Advertise
      • Collection Notice
      • Copyright
      • Contact
      • About Us
      © The Catholic Weekly 2021 | All Rights Reserved | ABN 60 471 267 587
      MORE STORIES

      Call for prayers after death of Archbishop Philip Wilson

      January 18, 2021

      Philippa Martyr: Our giant credibility problem

      January 17, 2021