Tolkien Review: The early years of greatness

Reading Time: 3 minutes
Nicholas Hoult plays J.R.R. Tolkien to Lily Collins’s Edith Bratt in a scene from Tolkien. Photo: CNS photo/Fox Searchlight
Nicholas Hoult plays J.R.R. Tolkien to Lily Collins’s Edith Bratt in a scene from Tolkien. Photo: CNS photo/Fox Searchlight

By turns lyrical and moving, Tolkien is a sophisticated profile of the future novelist’s youth that succeeds on a number of levels.

This may not be the biography that every fan of Catholic author J.R.R. Tolkien (1892-1973) is looking for, and it may not even fully accomplish what its makers set out to achieve.

But, if nothing else, it does tell the story of the young Tolkien and his times.

Director Dome Karukoski and screenwriters David Gleeson and Stephen Beresford trace Tolkien’s passage from orphaned and impoverished schoolboy (Harry Gilby) to Oxford University scholarship student and beleaguered officer in the trenches of World War I (Nicholas Hoult).

Beginning with Tolkien’s quest to locate a friend and fellow soldier during the 1916 Battle of the Somme, extended flashbacks take us to earlier periods both happy and sad.

Most significantly, they show us how Tolkien bonded with a trio of precociously gifted peers – Geoffrey Smith (Anthony Boyle), Robert Gilson (Patrick Gibson) and Christopher Wiseman (Tom Glynn-Carney) – and fell for his future wife, Edith (Lily Collins).

After a shaky start at Oxford, Tolkien also eventually finds his initial vocation as a philologist after coming under the spell of magisterial professor of that subject, Joseph Wright (Derek Jacobi).

How the Somme shaped Tolkien’s stories

As Tolkien wanders the scarred, mud-ridden landscape of the battlefield, vague visions of huge dragons and galloping warriors emerge from, then return behind, the smoke of war.

This suggests that Karukoski and his collaborators are intent on showing how his service in the global conflict shaped Tolkien’s most famous works, his 1937 novel The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings trilogy published 1954-55.

If so, however, the connection between real life and Middle-Earth remains elusive.

Certainly, the horrors of Tolkien’s experience may have inspired his portrayal of the forces of darkness and the travails to which his adventurers are subjected.

And the deep friendship shared by the members of the club Tolkien and his pals formed may be reflected in the fictional fellowship referred to in one of his titles.

Representing role of Tolken’s Faith in the film

But none of this is clearly or satisfactorily delineated in the film. As for the strong faith that also contributed to Tolkien’s outlook, its only representative is Father Francis (Colm Meaney), the caring but stern priest who served as his guardian after the death of both his parents.

This may leave Catholic moviegoers feeling somewhat cheated, though it’s not clear how strong a hold religion had on Tolkien in these early stages of his life.

What the creators of “Tolkien” are most successful in capturing is the broad range of emotions to which their protagonist must have been subjected by his varied fortunes.

Thus the buoyant camaraderie that led the imaginative, artistically inclined quartet to regard themselves as brothers gives way, in the poignant latter part of the movie, to the grim fate in which they were all caught up and the toll it exacted on them.

The film contains some harsh combat violence, a few gruesome images and a bit of slightly bawdy humour.

Related article: