Sydney
27 May 2001

Night under stars aids homeless

Parties will be ‘judged on poverty’

Bishop Brennan in hospital

‘Nothing new’ in new Vatican texts on liturgy

Swans score a win with Centacare team

‘Pray for those giving you a hard time’ – Archbishop

Tax office looks to get teeth into main menu of Magnificat Meal

‘Dun Georg’ – beatification of Malta’s ‘man of miracles’

Week of Prayer for Christian Unity and Reconciliation

Editorial: Christians owe much to Jewish tradition

Letters: Bishops’ help for mothers’ unborn

Converted by movie and Mother Teresa: Shigeki Chiba, Japanese documentary maker

Reflection: If we go to war with China

Poor languish as debt rebounds on Jakarta

Hope among the ruins in East Timor

Casimir students and staff give from own pockets

ACU opens new nursing labs

Kogarah chooses 20th century saints

27 May 01

Tax office looks to get teeth into main menu of Magnificat Meal



Debra Geileskey, founder of MMM, claims to have had visions of Mary





By Chris Hook



Magnificat Meal Movement (MMM) founders Debra and Gordon Geileskey are being investigated by the Australian Taxation Office (ATO), according to Brisbane’s Courier-Mail newspaper.

The newspaper says an ATO spokesperson has confirmed the investigation and said allegations of unconscionable conduct and criminal fraud would be forwarded to the Australian Federal Police.

However, an ATO spokesperson told The Catholic Weekly that the ATO did not confirm investigations of individuals.

Queensland’s Office of Fair Trading has also examined a cheap home loans scheme promoted by a business linked to Ms Geileskey. Advertisements boast a three per cent loan but borrowers are expected to pay a $300 joining fee plus annual subscription fees.

Debra Geileskey founded the MMM as a devotional Marian group in Melbourne in 1990.

In 1993, following a disagreement with the local parish priest, she and husband Gordon moved to Toowoomba, Queensland, and began to hold prayer groups and Saturday devotions under the MMM banner.

But after another falling out with a local priest, the pair moved to Helidon, a small town in the Toowoomba diocese. The Geileskeys and another couple then bought an old convent behind the Catholic church.

Up to 50 families had moved into the area to join the MMM by 1999.

Ms Geileskey had left the local parish by then and was holding devotional meetings exclusively at the old convent, renamed the Shrine of Mary.

The Bishop of Toowoomba, William Morris, established a commission in 1997 to investigate the MMM, taking the findings – and MMM publications – to Rome.

The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith warned that the evidence presented by Bishop Morris showed the MMM “constitutes a clear danger to a good many people”.

Reports of the ATO and Fair Trading investigations come in the wake of revelations in January that Ms Geileskey had begun selling Herbalife, a herb-based slimming program.

Herbalife is similar in structure to Amway in that a supplier – in this case Ms Geileskey – buys the product in bulk and then on-sells it at a profit to distributors. MMM members are expected to distribute the product.

Ms Geileskey has been raising money for many years for a proposed 7,000-seat basilica in Helidon. She has claimed God told her to build the basilica. Zoning approval has not yet been granted.

Wal Maggs, a former MMM member who was the movement’s publications officer, says that members who are not willing to sell the Herbalife products are treated like “second-class citizens”.

Wal Maggs and his wife Beth became involved with MMM in 1994 and moved to Helidon in 1996. Later their two married daughters joined them – a common practice among MMM families.

Mr Maggs said the attraction lay in the group’s devotional meetings and joyful celebrations. It was very beautiful in the beginning,” Mr Maggs said.

“In a way they provided a lot of things parishes don’t provide. This was Fantasia, we had everything.”

And Ms Geileskey is a charismatic figure who claims to have had visions of Our Lady. But as her claims became more extravagant, Wal and Beth Maggs became suspicious.

“We dropped out when it became apparent she was losing the faith,” he said.

In 1999, the Maggs family took a two- week holiday away from Helidon, then returned in secrecy, changed the locks at home, changed their telephone number and resigned from the MMM.

Wal Maggs then wrote a letter of apology to Bishop Morris and began working on a book, An End Times Tragedy: the case against Debra Geileskey and the Magnificat Meal Movement.

Mr Maggs said he wrote the book to alert people to the dangers of the MMM. He and his wife still have friends in the MMM whom they are trying to persuade to leave.

“We constantly try,” Mr Maggs said. “We don’t get very far. It’s like chipping away at a mountain. But we are getting there.”

And Fr John Ryan, Heldon’s parish priest, warmly welcomes those families who do leave – about 22 so far – into the life of the parish.

Mr Maggs said the experience has worked to deepen his faith and love of the Church. “It’s opened my eyes,” he said.

The MMM has attracted other media attention in recent times. The ABC’s Compass program is to screen a documentary on the MMM on Sunday May 27.

Compass reporter Geoff Wood said: “Debra Geileskey could be described as the Pauline Hanson of the Australian Roman Catholic Church.

“She’s an arch conservative and a renegade who has struck an emotional chord with a disenfranchised minority, unhappy with where the Church is headed.”

The program examines internal power struggles, various business dealings and allegations that the MMM is essentially a cult.



Slaves of the Eucharist, Compass, ABC TV, 10.20pm Sunday, May 27. Copies of the Wal Maggs book, An End Times Tragedy: the Case Against Debra Geileskey and the Magnificat Meal Movement, may be obtained by contacting Fr John Ryan, PO Box 38, Helidon, 4344.