Sydney
18 March 2001

Bishop: bad treatment of outworkers

World unsafe for women

Human cloning condemned

New Bishop of Sandhurst

World Day of Prayer

Catholic Education head defends public schools

Catholic Education head defends public schools

The ongoing terror of being a woman

More silence than ever about female torture

Editorial: St Patrick – the first anti-slavery protester

Letters: Who are sons of the Church?

My captors, my friends: Cardinal Francois Xavier Nguyen Van Thuan

Reflection: Where will charity move now?

Australia’s battlers making ends meet

Obituary: Death of pioneering Grail leader

Work-life – getting the balance right

Under the oak tree: The gentle one

New seminarians for a new millennium

18 Mar 01

Human cloning condemned

By Kathleen Carmody

Scientists and religious worldwide have condemned plans by an Italian professor to clone human beings.

Italian scientist Professor Severino Antinori and Professor Panayiotis Zavos from the United States announced their plans at a conference of the Italian Society of Reproductive Medicine last week, saying cloning could be considered the last frontier to overcome male sterility.

“We do intend to clone the first human,” Professor Antinori said. “This is a solution to a human problem.”

However, scientists have warned of the likelihood of birth defects in cloned babies, such as Down’s Syndrome, as well as heart, lung and blood vessel problems.

Church groups in Australia have been angered by the news of the human cloning experiments and have condemned the research outright, saying cloning is an affront to God and to human dignity.

“It is irresponsible and immoral for Professor Severino Antinori and Professor Panayiotis Zavos to announce their expectation of success in human cloning,” said Mr Ray Hoekzema, President of the NSW Council of Churches. “The arrogance of their claims is unbelievable … What they are seeking to do is an affront to God.”

Cloning in Australia is illegal and while it has been reported that some Australian research teams have the technology to undertake human cloning, they have held off because of ethical and legal questions.

The treatment Professor Antinori plans to carry out is banned in the US and most European countries, but the professor said an unnamed Mediterranean country had granted his team permission to set up a clinic there.

“A team of experts is ready, we have the financial backing and we will succeed in creating the world’s first (cloned) baby,” said Professor Antinori.

The Vatican described the plan as immoral.

“Every child must be born with his or her genetic individuality – they should not be simply a photocopy,” said Monsignor Mauro Cozzoli of the Vatican’s Bioethics Commission.