Sydney
8 July 2001

Second papal honour for Dr Pell

Sydney students bid for World Youth Day in 2004

Treatment of detainees ‘amounts to torture’

Red Cross hero of Fiji hostage crisis murdered

Sir William – always going the extra mile

Go ahead for brothel near Catholic colleges

Cloud over human rights, despite positive reports

40th birthday for PALMS

Women’s forum to celebrate the Good Samaritans’ centenary

New director for CCI

Bishop Ingham’s installation

Editorial: Populate or perish?

Letters: Awakening

The gift of prison: Fr Paul Van Chi, songwriter, priest, ‘faith’ prisoner

Reflection: If Labor wants to win, it must act now

Racism, refugees and an empty taxi

Two Australias report defended over proposal on wealth gap

No stereotypes: students zero in on social justice

Obituary: Lover of sport and man of faith, Fr Tom Finn

Obituary: Norman ‘the builder’ – at all times a priest of the people, Fr Norm Grady

Education: Affordable school holiday dreaming

Inspirations: The rise of the ‘reluctant’ Catholics

8 Jul 01

Treatment of detainees ‘amounts to torture’



Bishop William Morris ... “it happens all around the world”





By Kathleen Carmody



Some elements of Australia’s detention regime for asylum seekers amount to torture, says the Australian Catholic Social Justice Council.

The acting chairman of the council, Bishop William Morris, made the comments last week on the International Day in Support of Survivors of Torture.

“It would be easy for us, in a country like Australia, to think that this (torture) isn’t relevant to our community,” he said. “(But) it happens all around the world, including our region.

“On this International Day in Support of Survivors of torture and trauma we must ask ourselves: ‘How well have we as a nation welcomed and supported survivors of torture’?”

Bishop Morris said the country’s detention centres held people who were desperate and had come to Australia seeking asylum.

They should not be labelled ‘illegal’ when they were exercising their right under international humanitarian law to seek asylum without necessarily having a visa.

Bishop Morris compared some procedures in Australia’s detention centres to torture.

 “At certain stages in their processing, asylum seekers in detention are not allowed to contact their families,” he said.

“Unlike those convicted of a criminal offence, asylum seekers do not know for how long they will be detained.

“In some immigration detention centres, observations and musters involve waking asylum seekers at night or shining torches on them while they are sleeping.

“Do elements of our immigration centre regime amount to torture?”

Bishop Morris said that human dignity was at the centre of Catholic thinking about human rights and social justice; torture was a profound attack on human dignity.

In torture the victim is treated as something less than human and the perpetrator becomes less human. “Respect for human dignity and human rights calls us to act to stop torture in whatever way we can,” he said.

The Australian Social Justice Council has called on people to take action in support of survivors of torture by:

•including torture survivors in prayers of the faithful during Mass;

•praying for both survivors and inflictors of torture;

•visiting asylum seekers in detention;

•providing financial support to services for survivors;

•reading the writings of Cardinal Francois-Xavier Nguyen Van Thuan, president of the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace and former Amnesty International prisoner of conscience;

•visiting the Amnesty International website (www.amnesty.org.au) to make use of resource material for action against torture.