Sydney
8 July 2001

Second papal honour for Dr Pell

Sydney students bid for World Youth Day in 2004

Treatment of detainees ‘amounts to torture’

Red Cross hero of Fiji hostage crisis murdered

Sir William – always going the extra mile

Go ahead for brothel near Catholic colleges

Cloud over human rights, despite positive reports

40th birthday for PALMS

Women’s forum to celebrate the Good Samaritans’ centenary

New director for CCI

Bishop Ingham’s installation

Editorial: Populate or perish?

Letters: Awakening

The gift of prison: Fr Paul Van Chi, songwriter, priest, ‘faith’ prisoner

Reflection: If Labor wants to win, it must act now

Racism, refugees and an empty taxi

Two Australias report defended over proposal on wealth gap

No stereotypes: students zero in on social justice

Obituary: Lover of sport and man of faith, Fr Tom Finn

Obituary: Norman ‘the builder’ – at all times a priest of the people, Fr Norm Grady

Education: Affordable school holiday dreaming

Inspirations: The rise of the ‘reluctant’ Catholics

8 Jul 01

Reflection: If Labor wants to win, it must act now

By Andrew Murray SM



We are facing a federal election some time this year on a date of the Prime Minister’s choosing. It will more than likely be after the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting in October, because Mr Howard wants to see the Queen – and she will not come to CHOGM if an election has been called.

Electioneering has begun in spasmodic fashion, and an election budget has been brought down. The Labor Party, however, is proving slow to articulate policies that are likely to inspire voters. There are a number of plausible reasons for this.

Since the date of the election is in the Prime Minister’s hands, Labor is unlikely to want to spill the beans too soon, thus leaving nothing to propose closer to the election. On matters of economic management the differences between the parties have got so small that any decent proposals Labor makes are likely to be taken up by the Government. Since Hewson’s defeat, it has been thought that an opposition ought simply to wear a government down rather than take the risky path of proposing alternatives.

There is a way around this for the Labor Party and that is to go back to its roots, when, as a party representing workers, it fought for justice for those who needed it most. Who needs it most may have changed, but there is plenty to be done, and anything that contributes to justice improves the general moral quality of the community.

Such a move would put a distance between Labor and the conservative parties that could not be taken up by adjustments to policy. Conservatism in the modern political sense holds that the status quo and the existing establishment is better or safer than any likely alternative and is sceptical towards proposals for social change. By recovering its interest in social justice, the Labor Party could readily re-establish its own ground.

On Social Justice Sunday in September last year, I identified three areas of Australian life where justice is lacking: growing inequality in the distribution of wealth and opportunity in our community; on-going issues surrounding Aboriginal reconciliation, the effects of treatment Aboriginal peoples have received and our attempts to rectify this; our response to the needs of asylum seekers in Australia, that is, of people who have fled their own homelands because of intolerable conditions and who, having found their way here, are asking to stay. More complex is the amalgam of international issues ranging from the effects of globalisation to the means of assuring human rights.

Labor lost its way when its traditional constituents became wealthy. It has, perhaps, also been slow to recover from the shock of the sacking of Gough Whitlam and his failed attempt at rapid and radical change. If it is to act, now is the time to do so, because justice is not won quickly, and minds are won only slowly.

Fr Murray teaches philosophy at the Catholic Institute of Sydney.