Sydney
22 April 2001

On top of the world

Ruddock takes on Social Justice Council: Immigration Minister claims refugee centres are better than many Australian homes

Cardinal Clancy in stable condition following surgery

Secular press helps build interfaith relations – by mistake

John Paul II Institute to take students from July

Deputy Ridgeway – a first for Aborigines

International meeting of Good Samaritan Sisters

Our readers help raise $24,000 towards ‘rubbish dump’ childcare centre

Call for Catholic parents to enter schools debate

Dutch euthanasia “cheap solution” – Right to Life

Church backs parental leave for casuals

East Timor’s Bishop Belo to receive honorary degree

Quo vadis adoption? The search goes on …

Editorial: Abortion is forever too

Letters: Injustice and poverty

One Nation spectre gave birth to Unity: Dr Peter Wong MLC

Reflection: On the future of Anzac Day

Titanic mystery shares stage with classics

Wrapping up basic education

Celebrating women and family

22 Apr 01

Dutch euthanasia “cheap solution” – Right to Life

By Dan McAloon



The decision of the Dutch Parliament to introduce the world’s first pro-euthanasia law is a tragedy for the people of the Netherlands and highlights the failure of that country’s health system to address the needs of the gravely sick and dying, the president of the NSW Right to Life, Mr Greg Smith said.

“The unpublicised aspect of this story is that in the Netherlands there is so little palliative care that many facing death feel there is no alternative to this immoral and inhuman act,” said Mr Smith.

On a trip to Amsterdam in 1996, Mr Smith said he had been able to find only one hospice containing seven beds in the whole city.

“And there has been little improvement since then. Palliative care remains the merciful way to care for the dying. But (this law) offers the cheap solution to medical care for the dying – the quick fix, the lethal dose, the legally-sanctioned taking of human life.”

Mr Smith said his sympathies went to those MPs from Dutch Christian parties who, in trying to block the bill, had argued that the law would increase pressure on doctors and patients to request killing on demand.

“It’s a tragedy for all Christians that the Netherlands’ reputation for courage and moral fibre should decline so gravely because of this law.”

Replying to media reports that Australian euthanasia campaigner Dr Phillip Nitschke plans to set up a euthanasia clinic on a Dutch-registered ship anchored in international waters off the Australian coast, Mr Smith said pro-life groups had already received assurances from the Dutch government that they would not cooperate in the plan.

“Nitschke has been talking up the idea of this boat for a year. He will do and say anything to get publicity,” said Mr Smith, who blamed irresponsible reporting by the media for the latest report.